First of Several Homeowners Insurance Cases Ruled on by N.C. Court of Appeals
In a 3-0 decision handed down on April 20, 2010, the NC Court of Appeals dismissed one of the three cases pending before the NC Court of Appeals regarding the 2008 homeowners insurance rate increases. This decision refers to case 09-701 which was heard by the Court of Appeals on January 14, 2010 by judges Calabria, Geer and Stephens. This challenge was a direct appeal to the Court of Appeals filed in late 2008 by Dare County, et al.
The Ruling States the Following: By its plain language, N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-2-80 does not apply to the Consent Order. Since a direct appeal of the Consent Order to this Court is not authorized by statute, this Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction to hear this appeal. The instant case must be dismissed.
Click below to read the Opinion
http://www.aoc.state.nc.us/www/public/coa/opinions/2010/pdf/090701-1.pdf
Effectively, the Court has decided that the Coastal Counties, coastal citizens and other impacted parties do not have the ability to make a direct appeal to the Court of Appeals for a rate decision by the Department of Insurance and the Rate Bureau. Since this route is not authorized by statute, the Court does not have the jurisdiction to hear this appeal. This is an unfortunate decision, but the remaining legal challenges heard last week remain in play.
Oral arguments were held last week at the N.C. Court of Appeals in the remaining homeowner’s insurance cases brought by the coastal counties. The cases heard by the Court of Appeals were case 09-1171 and case 09-1172, which were combined in November 2009. These cases are the continuation of challenges to the Commissioner of Insurance and Wake County Superior Court regarding the massive homeowners insurance increases approved in 2008. For some coastal citizens these increases meant a 30% increase in basic homeowners insurance.
“In spite of these legal challenges, the cumulative impact of continued homeowners insurance increases are tremendously detrimental to our coastal communities and eastern North Carolina as a whole. To mitigate further increases, the Business Alliance for A Sound Economy (BASE) worked with local governments, state lawmakers, citizens and industry partners to pass legislation that would create a compromise on the increases to the Beach Plan during the last legislative session. However, the increases to homeowner’s insurance rates still remain unchanged thus leading the coastal counties to take legal action,” said Donna Girardot, CEO of BASE.
“BASE has maintained that we need statewide equity in homeowners rates, affordability and availability for consumers and a stable and predictable environment to encourage companies to write policies statewide,” adds Girardot. “We also believe there should be a venue for our voices to be heard during the ratemaking process.”
Dare County led the charge in hiring the Williams Mullen Law Firm to initiate four separate legal proceedings, including a lawsuit and an appeal to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, challenging Beach Plan increases and homeowners rate increases as approved by the NC Department of Insurance in late 2008. A number of local governments, including the Town of Southern Shores, Duck, Nags Head, Kill Devil Hills, Pine Knoll Shores, Emerald Isle, Indian Beach, Kitty Hawk, Surf City, and the Counties of Dare, Currituck, Beaufort, New Hanover, Pender, Brunswick, Craven, Carteret, Hyde, and Washington agreed to join the challenges as named parties and to provide financial support.
However, in April 2009, another trial court’s order dismissed the appellants (Dare County, et al) petition for review for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and lack of standing. This judgment was made by Wake County Superior Court Judge Ronald Stephens. Now it is up to the Court of Appeals to decide on case 09-1171 and case 09-1172.
For questions, a copy of the legal documents or additional information, please contact BASE at (910)799-2611 or visit www.ncbase.org
About Author
